Mrs. Zimmerman's Third Grade G & T Class ​at Chelsea Prep
  • Home
  • Meet our Teacher
    • Mrs. Z's Educational Values
  • Info for 344 Families
    • Wish List
    • Weekly Schedule
    • Homework
    • Scholastic Book Club Info
  • Math Matters
    • Math Resources to Download
  • Math Links
    • Math Links: Fractions
    • Factor Games
    • "Greg Tang" Math
    • Math Links: Decimals
    • Place Value
    • Telling Time
    • Combinations of Ten
    • Estimation & Rounding
    • Function Machines/Algebraic Thinking
  • Web Assignments for Students
    • Fractions Web Center, 2015
    • Song of the Week
    • Peter Pan Junior Resources
    • Matter Unit Science Resources
    • The Great Debate: School Uniforms
    • Country Research Sources
    • Etymology Explorers: Learn About English!
    • Immigration Resources
    • Geography Center Activities
    • Exploring Maps and Globes
    • Practice the Preamble
    • The Pledge of Allegiance
    • We're Writing the Constitution!
    • Name Research Project
    • Let's Learn about Princeton!
  • Class Projects & Activities
    • 344 On the Map!
  • Photo Galleries
    • Photos, Week 2, 2014 (9/8-9/12)
    • Photos, Weeks 3-5 (9/15-10/3)
    • Vocabulary Parade 2014!
  • Literacy Links & Technology
    • iPods for Readers
  • Resources for Teachers
    • Teacher Week @ Scholastic Presentation Resources
    • BLC14 Presentation Resources
    • Tour Our Classroom >
      • Virtual Read-Aloud Bookshelf
    • Library Basket Labels
    • Labels & More to Organize
    • Daily Editing Paragraphs
    • Management Tools
    • Math Resources >
      • Math Activities
      • Math Games
      • Math Charts
      • Math Printables
      • Everyday Math Information for Families
    • Reader's Workshop Resources >
      • Thematic Book List: Names
      • Thematic Book List: Pourquoi Tales
      • Main Idea Centers
    • Weblinks to Sites I Use or Like
  • Contact Mrs. Zimmerman
  • General Archive
    • Past Web Assignments for Students >
      • Learn about Princeton University!, 13-14
      • World Geography Projects, 13-14
      • Place Value Web Center, 13-14
      • Area/Perimeter Web Center, 13-14
      • States of Matter Web Research, 13-14
      • Follow the Drinking Gourd: The Underground Railroad and Harriet Tubman, 13-14
      • Matter Movies & Songs, 13-14
      • College Fair 2014: Princeton Tigers!
      • Fractions Web Center, 2014
      • Your Weight On Other Worlds Graphing
      • Etymology Explorers
      • Xtranormal Moviemaking
      • Math Movies to Watch
      • Exploring the Land Down Under
      • Main Idea Web Center
      • Matter Movies
      • Perfect Pet Research
      • Don't Be Dense! Density Research
      • Magnetic Poetry Activity
      • Earth Day Web Quest
      • Main Idea Web Center
      • Tangram Exploration
      • Reading and Writing Reviews
      • Math Workstation of the Week
      • Ellis Island Webquest
      • Math Menu Movies
      • Very Big Number Research
      • Pourquoi Tales to Watch
      • Patricia Polacco Author Study
      • Spring Break "Training" Homework
      • Biographical Stamp Article
  • 2014-2015 Archive
    • Summer 2014 Homework & More
    • School Supply List 2014-2015 >
      • Bring Your Own Device (BYOD) Info for Families
    • 344 Behind the Scenes Blog
    • What Do YOU Think Blog
  • 2013-2014 Archive
    • Frog Blog 2014
    • College Fair 2014: Princeton Voki Movies
    • Book Club "Digital" Projects
    • Student Etymology Projects
    • Geography Projects, November 2013
    • Songs of the Week, 2013-2014
    • Photo Galleries, 2013-2014 >
      • Photos, Sept. 9-13
      • Photos, Sept. 16-20
      • Photos, Sept. 23-27
      • College "Prep" Rally
      • October Photo Galleries
      • November 2013 Photos
      • January 2014 Photos
      • February 2014 Photos
      • March 2014 Gallery
      • Spring Concert 2014
  • 2012-2013 Archive
    • The Hurricane Sandy Blog
    • 2012-2013 Photos >
      • Photos, Week of Sept 19-21
      • Photos, Week of Sept 10-14
      • Photos, Week of Oct 1-5
      • Photos, Week of Oct 9-12
      • Photos, Week of October 15-19
      • Photos, Week of Oct 22-26
      • Photos, Week of Nov 5-9
      • Photos, Weeks of Nov 14-21
      • Madame Tussaud's Field Trip, 11/28/12
      • Photos, Jan 2-11, 2013
      • Photos, Week of Jan. 14-18
      • MoMath Field Trip, 1/22/13
      • Photos, Week of 1/28-2/1
      • Photos, February 2013
      • Photos, March 2013
      • Princeton Trip Photos, May 2, 2013
      • Happy Mother's Day, 2013
    • Biography Avatar Movies
    • ANNIE Info and Practice
    • Web Assignments for Students, 2012-2013 >
      • Fractions Web Center 2013
      • Earth Month 2013 - Resources
      • College Fair 2013: Princeton Tigers!
      • Beethoven's Wig and More!
      • Immune System Research
      • Constitution Center Webquest
      • Decimal Web Center
      • Holiday Songs to Practice
      • Make Your Own Cyber Graph!
      • Practice: "Fifty, Nifty United States"
      • Book Browsing: Shop and Tell
  • 2011-2012 Archive
    • Perfectly Persuasive: Our Writing Blog
    • Class Projects, 2011-2012 >
      • Our Persuasive Movies
      • Practice singing 'Vive le Vent'
      • Class 344 Princeton Tigers
      • Noun as Image Project
    • Photo Galleries, 2011-2012 >
      • Class Photo, 2011-2012
      • Back to School, 2011
      • Fruit Gummy Bar Graphing Lesson
      • Our First Garden Visit, 9/16/11
      • Master Jones' Visit from Plimoth, 10/3/11
      • Kindergarten Reading Buddies Gallery
      • Misc. October Photos 2011
      • The Pumpkin Project, 2011!
      • NY Hall of Science Trip, Dec. 7 2011
      • March-April Photo Potpourri
      • Photos, Week of April 16-20
      • Photos from April 30-May 4
      • May 16 Music Concert - Bravo!
      • Photos - May 17-18
      • May 22-25 Videos & Photos
      • Field Day, May 30 2012
      • Solar Bag Balloon Movie
  • 2010-2011 Archive
    • Summer Info, 2011 >
      • Summer Reading, 2011
      • Pen-pal Letter Writing
      • Look What We're Reading This Summer
      • Summer Gardening
    • 2010-2011 Class Work & Projects >
      • Patricia Polacco Book Movies
      • Kandinsky Inspired Artwork
      • How-To Expert Presentations
      • The Poetry Corner >
        • September Poems
        • November Poems
      • Meet Our Robots
      • Meet Class 344 Similes
      • Garden Harvest "Cooking" Projects >
        • Caprese Crostini
        • Guacamole
      • Our Class Garden "Classroom"
    • 2010-2011 in Photos >
      • Class Photo, 2010-2011
      • Fall/Winter 2010 Galleries >
        • Garden Learning, 9/16/10
        • Project Guacamole, 10/7/10
        • Hard at Work, 10/2010
        • Supermarket Math, 10/14/10
        • Greenmarket Tour, 10/15/10
        • Grow & Glow Party, 10/21
        • October 2010 Misc. Photos
        • Halloween, 2010
        • Ellis Island, November 4, 2010
        • Our Multicultural Feast
        • Nutrition Musical Dance
        • The Whitney Museum Partnership
        • The Queens Museum of Art
      • Winter/Spring 2011 Galleries >
        • Dough Maps & More, 4/8/11
        • Chess Tourney, 3/18/11
        • College Fair 2011
        • AMNH Field Trip, 3/3/11
        • Geodesic Gumdrop Exploration, 3/2/11
        • Meet the College Classes of 2025 & 2026
        • Tadpole and Frog Photos
        • Busy Learning, January 2011
        • Snow Fun, January 28, 2011
        • Guggenheim Field Trip, 2/7/11
        • Pysanky Egg Painting, 4/29/2011
        • Our Soil Delivery! May 6, 2011
        • "Gridding" Our Raised Beds, 5/9/11
        • Planting Day! 5/10/11
        • Garden Measurement Math, 5/13/11
        • Historic Richmond Town Field Trip, 5/16/11
        • Princeton Trip, 5/23/11
        • Mets Game Field Trip
        • Track & Field Trip, 6/10/11
        • Fishing Trip, June 16 2011
        • Field Day, June 17, 2011
    • 2010-2011 Events and Trips >
      • Union Square Greenmarket Trip, 10/15/10
      • Glow & Grow Pub. Party, 10/21/10
      • Ellis Island Field Trip, 11/4/10
      • Guggenheim Field Trip, Feb 7, 2011
    • Our Frog Blog
  • 2009-2010 Archive
    • Class Projects & Activities 09-10 >
      • College Fair 2010: Princeton Tigers!
      • Aladdin, the Musical
      • Book Review Movies 09-10
      • Hooked on Poetry 09-10 >
        • Our Poetry Display 09-10
        • September Poetry 09-10
        • October Poetry 09-10
      • Chess in Class 09-10
      • Personal Narratives, Round 1 09-10
      • The Secret Lives of Third Graders 09-10
    • Summer Reading, 2010 >
      • Summer Book Recommendations
    • Class Events, Trips, and News 09-10 >
      • Field Trips 09-10 >
        • Princeton Field Trip
        • MET Museum Field Trip
      • Celebrations 09-10
      • Class Newsletters 09-10 >
        • NYS Testing Information
      • Class Calendars 09-10
    • Photo Galleries 09-10 >
      • Picture Day Class Photos 09-10
      • Fishing Trip, June 2010
      • Princeton Field Trip Photos
      • Chess Tournament, June 3 2010
      • Apple Store Field Trip
      • Silk Painting Photos 2010
      • Earth Day Posters 2010
      • College Fair 2010 Photo Gallery
      • Book Release Party Photos
      • Holiday Show Photo Gallery
      • AMNH Trip Photo Gallery
      • Halloween Photos
      • Pumpkin Project Photo Gallery 09-10
      • Assorted Photos of Learning and Playing
    • Math Matters 09-10 >
      • Math Resources to Download 09-10
      • Our Number Story Movies 09-10
    • Word Study 09-10 >
      • NYS Editing Passages
      • Perfect Paper Club
    • Homework 09-10 >
      • Reading Responses >
        • Reading Response Forms
      • Practice Test Answer Keys
  • The Math Playgroup
    • About the Math Playgroup
    • Math through Games & More
    • Testimonials
    • FAQ
    • Private Tutoring
  • Tom Otterness Public Art Project

Fiction or Nonfiction? By Catherine

1/3/2012

9 Comments

 
Picture
You rush home. You plop down on your bed. You take out your favorite fiction book, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince. Then suddenly you remember your parents telling you fiction is a true waste of your time. You shake off that thought like a dog shaking off water. Then suddenly your mom's voice is ringing in your ears. "I know you're reading fiction; how many times do I have to tell you, fiction is a true waste of time!" Or is it, Mom? I strongly believe reading fiction is not a waste of time. I think this because fiction is fun, it builds big minds and imaginations, and it also is the perfect place to find juicy vocabulary and great story plots.


Picture
First of all, fiction is fun. Instead of nonfiction, which drones on and on, fiction is action packed. There is also a lot of surprises in fiction that are not in nonfiction. Easier fiction books can be enjoyable read alouds to young kids, performing a task nonfiction can't play because the kids won't understand more technical nonfiction texts.

Another reason why fiction is not a waste of time is because fiction builds big minds and imaginations. For example, kids will start thinking about the characters in their fiction books. They can think as "big" and as "far" as they want while imagining the characters, thus allowing readers to think learn to think freely. Kids can start thinking about the impossible, and then twist together a story in their minds, thinking big thoughts so wonderfully nursed from fiction.

Lastly, fiction always has great story plots and vocabulary. In a fiction book, I learned the words adequate and macabre. Fiction carries lots of juicy adjectives. The plots in fiction are also always a surprise; anything can happen. This wonderful aspect of plot makes the story more enjoyable. Nonfiction is often so predictable, that sometimes it gets so boring leaving a reader in a great need for a fiction twist. An example of this nonfiction/fiction twist is the science fiction genre. Fiction authors kick off with a captivating beginning, taking readers on a magical journey or words. Nonfiction glues the reader's feet down.

According to the contrary point of view, kids need to read information to fill their brains. This is really not true, though, because information can be filled in at school and through homework. (In fact, that's another reason why there should be homework.) In the meantime, kids can have FUN with fiction. A little bit of nonfiction is necessary, but readers enjoy fiction more and should be allowed to read plenty of it.

In my opinion, reading fiction is NOT a waste of time. Fiction is not a time waster because it is fun to read, it builds big minds and imaginations, and fiction authors use superb story plots and vocabulary. The next time your parents are telling you sternly that fiction is a real waste of time, why don't you read them this?

9 Comments
Susan
1/4/2012 11:05:51 am

That is interesting Catherine....Katya's brother, Zeke, only wants to read non-fiction and I need to force him to read fiction...maybe your mom and I should talk about this because I think both are important!!!!!

Reply
Catherine
1/4/2012 10:02:59 pm

Now that's interesting. In my home, my mom and dad try to force me to read non-fiction. I agree, my mom and you should talk( my dad feels a bit more strongly, so you might contact my dad).

Reply
Chloe
1/5/2012 08:06:10 am

Awesome essay Catherine I totally agree

Reply
Gina Valeri
1/5/2012 11:28:35 pm

I second everything that's been said...and I want to add that some of the fiction that I have read in my life has stayed in my memory and I call on it from time to time to pick me up from a bad mood, or to help me remember an important life lesson that I wouldn't have understood from reading it as nonfiction. Thanks for your wonderful essay.

Reply
NATHALIE HOROWICZ-MEHLER
1/7/2012 07:21:42 am

Dear Catherine,

I enjoyed reading your post very much and found your position well articulated.

While I do agree that the author has more leeway in terms of plot (after all he or she is not constrained by the realm of the possible), I also want to share that biographies of truly inspirational people move me in a way fictional characters cannot. The courage and strength individuals show in the face of adversity makes me a huge believer in humankind. After all, isn't it harder to be a real-life hero than the savior in a fictional drama?

Hopefully, we do not have to pick one genre to the detriment of others but can enjoy many styles and authors.

Can you think of a fictional book your mom might enjoy reading so that she can better understand your attraction to fiction?

Sincerely,
Nathalie

Reply
jake
1/7/2012 09:31:42 pm

I totally agree because in fiction anything can happen.

Reply
Ms. MB's 3rd grade class
5/14/2012 03:04:20 am

Hi Catherine,

We are writing to you from a third grade class in Detroit and we were so impressed with your writing! My class agrees - we love to read fiction. Thank you for persuading us with your thoughtful and well-written essay.

All the best,

Ms. MB's class

Reply
Nicole Short link
4/6/2019 09:22:31 pm

Great post Catherine!

Reply
Krish
5/18/2020 06:55:59 pm

I'm reading this 8 years later and I still totally agree

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    The Class 344 Writers

    These third graders have some strong opinions and they are not afraid to share them. Read on for their opinions on all sorts of topics ranging from dodgeball to feminism. Then PLEASE share your thoughts in the comments sections below the posts. The writers would love to know whether you agree or disagree with their points of view. All respectfully worded opinions are welcome! Let the debates begin...

    Categories

    All
    Fiction
    Gender
    Legos
    Opinion
    Reading
    Recess
    Smoking

    RSS Feed